Newsroom
Exactly Who Is Behind Google’s Grab for “White Space?" PDF Print E-mail
Written by Chris Bray
WASHINGTON — As a bunch of news stories have recently explained, two sides are fighting over control of “white spaces” in the broadcast spectrum that are currently used for wireless microphones. On one side, the greedy scofflaws of the audio industry and their clients in businesses like live music and theater. On the other side, the apple-cheeked American consumer, pulling his child around the block in a bright red American Flyer wagon. (They’re on their way to buy a slice of apple pie. From a military veteran. At the local volunteer firehouse.)


Now, sure: A giant corporation, Google, has taken an interest in the same issue, and companies invested in the Internet would like to sell new services over those broadcast frequencies. In fact, Google started a website, freetheairwaves.com, to promote the commercial use of the “unused” radio airwaves that wireless microphones use. But we’re not talking about Google, here — they just happen to be on the same side as the ordinary American. “Consumer groups,” reports the Associated Press, have alleged in an FCC complaint that users of wireless microphones are violating federal regulations by using those unused airwaves.

Consumer groups? The AP goes on:

“The Public Interest Spectrum Coalition accused manufacturers of deceptive advertising in how they market and sell the microphones, which largely operate in the same radio spectrum as broadcast television stations.”

The Public Interest Spectrum Coalition. Here we go. In an April 5, 2007 regulatory filing before the FCC, that group identified itself as an “ad hoc” association — that is, a cluster of disparate organizations, informally banded together to address a single common concern.

Among the organizations making up this ad hoc consumer coalition is the New America Foundation, a Washington, D.C. non-profit. It’s a pretty connected organization — it even turns out that the chairman of the board is Eric Schmidt, the CEO of Google. In fairness, Eric Schmidt probably does buy stuff at the store, so it’s not a stretch for him to stand in for America’s consumers — he has experience in the field.

Another member of the PISC is the Media Access Project, also a D.C. non-profit. The names of the project’s board of directors are available online. Director Kathleen Wallman is an erstwhile lobbyist for clients like AT&T and the U.S. Telecom Association, according to lobbyist filings obtained by OpenSecrets.org. Board member Albert Kramer, a partner at the law firm of Dickstein Shapiro, LLC, is the former general counsel to the North American Telecommunications Association. According to his law firm’s Web site, Kramer’s clients now include internet service providers and VoIP companies — just the kind of ordinary American consumers who unselfishly yearn to “free the white space.”

Democracy at work: In our nation’s capital, Vegans for Fairness to Animals would be an organization of slaughterhouse operators. And the news reports would take everything they said at face value.

You can check out all of this information for yourself, by the way — it’s easy to find. Just Google it.


Dont get FRONT of HOUSE? Click here to subscribe now.




What are your thoughts?

Comment by GUEST on 2008-08-26 16:31:26
Last Friday FCC released a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and Order in Docket 08-166 dealing with the wireless microphone issue. 
 
From 08-166: 
 
In the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (Notice) below, we tentatively conclude to amend our rules to make clear 
that the operation of low power auxiliary stations within the 700 MHz Band will no longer be permitted after the end of the DTV transition because such operations could cause harmful interference to new public safety and commercial wireless services in the band. We also tentatively conclude to prohibit themanufacture, import, sale, offer for sale, or shipment of devices that operate as low power auxiliary 
stations in the 700 MHz Band. 
 

Comment by GUEST on 2008-08-26 16:49:17
My opinion... Hmmm.. if the public wants to pay more for tickets to shows then go ahead and let people "buy up" the whitespace. Otherwise leave it like it is and have these companies that want to make money on frequency spectrum use another area of the spectrum. 

Comment by GUEST on 2008-08-26 17:12:42
Just another fine example of humans over using our "natural resources" for personal gain untill there's nothing left. Sad.

Comment by GUEST on 2008-08-26 22:48:51
Lets go through one week of noisy microphones on the television stations and during football games and see how many complaints come in!

Comment by GUEST on 2008-08-27 13:22:47
The talking heads that take everything at face value had better take notice of this situation as it will effect EVERY radio and tv station across the nation. Every one of these fine American organizations benefit from the very service that they deem illegal. Try and hold a press conference without any wireless audio, ENG, film, church and of course live concerts. Have they really thought this thing through? 
Just so they can have better internet at the coffee shop?

Comment by GUEST on 2008-08-27 21:32:53
So with all of these millions of dollars these music artist make, where is thier uprising? They suffer worse than the guy in the park execising his freedom of speach through a small Fender PA and a Shure cheapo wireless (So he can get in your face and \"Let Ya Know\"), who is the real target market in this \"for your best intersts\" campaing. It will be the next media candy child WAR. As if Iraq isn\'t enough, or the drug war. Being the guy in the park, I\'ll just yell louder. As a union stagehand, we used wires once, they cost too much in fuel transportaion cost magins. This is what happens when big buisness rules our daily lives so we don\'t have to.

Comment by GUEST on 2008-08-28 10:05:48
These companies would not have ANY interest in the white spaces if they didn't have selfish money making ideas that will surely make them a profit. They will not waste their time for sake of "Fairness" because the touring industry is using these open airwaves. They are just using the "non-profit" industry as a front for other companies they are part of to open the spaces and start using technology that will be sold to the public. If their technology is so great, why would simple 10mw to 250mw systems that we use even affect them? Money is the motivation for their lobbying.

Security Check. Please enter this code Listen to code

<Previous   Next>